Buying your first home is one of the biggest financial decisions you’ll ever make. For a lot of people, it’s wrapped up in all kinds of emotions: security, pressure, excitement, and sometimes fear of missing out. But here’s the thing. There’s no universal right time to buy. Only the right time for you.

In this article, we’ll talk through the key questions and trade-offs to think about. The goal isn’t to talk you into or out of buying. It’s to help you decide if it fits your life, your money, and your priorities right now. 

Why are you buying in the first place?

Start by getting clear on your reasons. Buying your first home is emotional..and that’s okay. Maybe you’re looking to set down roots. Maybe you want space for a growing family. Or maybe you just want something that’s truly yours after years of renting.

Those are all valid motivations.

But I’ve also worked with clients who felt pressure to buy because it seemed like “the next adult thing to do.” They had the down payment, good credit, and a job that made it all possible. So why not?

Here’s the problem with that approach: when the decision isn’t grounded in your goals, it’s easy to end up with the wrong house, higher than anticipated expenses, or the wrong expectations altogether. 

Ask yourself:

  • What role do I want this home to play in my life?
  • How long do I expect to stay?
  • What would buying unlock for me, and what would it limit?

When your reason is clear, the rest of the plan becomes a lot easier to build. 

How much down payment is enough?

Everyone talks about putting 20% down like it’s the gold standard. And sometimes it can be viewed that way because it will allow you to avoid private mortgage insurance (an additional expense), reduce your loan amount, and you can qualify for better rates. But for many home buyers, putting down 5%-15% may be perfectly reasonable. 

If you’re in a strong cash position and can afford the monthly payment, it might be smarter to keep more cash liquid, especially if you’re also putting money aside for taxes, building an emergency fund, or investing elsewhere. 

We’ve had clients use RSUs, stock options, bonuses or even gifts from parents to help with their down payment. Just make sure you understand how it impacts your taxes and overall financial picture.

How much house can you afford?

Most people start with what a lender says they can afford. But smart planning starts with what you’re comfortable paying. Start with your full monthly housing cost, not just the mortgage. That means understanding PITI:

  • Principal: The loan amount you’re repaying
  • Interest: The cost of borrowing
  • Taxes: Property taxes (often escrowed and paid bundled with mortgage)
  • Insurance: Homeowner’s insurance and possibly PMI if you put down less than 20%

This gives you a realistic monthly number to visualize. A good rule of thumb is to keep these monthly housing costs below 28% of your income before taxes. But for folks in high-cost areas like NYC, LA, or SF, you might stretch to 35%. 

Example: If you make $15,000 per month, aim for housing costs under $4,200-$5,250. That should give you room to still save, invest and live your life comfortably. 

Don’t be fooled by your RSUs

If you work in tech and receive RSUs or other equity compensation, there are a few common mistakes to avoid when thinking about how much house you can afford:

  • Basing affordability on total compensation instead of base salary. Lenders might approve you based on your full comp package, including RSUs. But the value of your RSUs will fluctuate. Plan your home purchase based on your base salary, not your E*TRADE balance.
  • Counting RSUs as ongoing, reliable income. Stock refreshers aren’t always consistent. If your plan relies on equity continuing at current levels, you could be in trouble if the company changes direction or the stock underperforms.
  • Relying on RSU sales to cover your mortgage. If your PITI is only manageable when you sell RSUs regularly, what happens during a blackout window or if the share price drops? You’ll be better off if you tie your lifestyle to stable income, not a fluctuating stock price.
  • Treating unvested equity like cash. That $200K on paper isn’t spendable until it vests and you pay the taxes. Don’t overextend on a house expecting equity to float you. Plan around what’s already vested or soon vesting.

Long story short, buying a home with equity comp in the picture requires a different lens. You’ll need the right strategy to help you build a stable financial foundation without overextending yourself.

The real monthly cost of home ownership

Your mortgage is just the beginning. The real monthly cost of homeownership includes a long list of extras that don’t show up on the Zillow listing. We talked about property tax, which can add hundreds to your monthly budget, and varies wildly depending on where you live. As well as homeowners insurance, which tends to be pricier if you’re in areas prone to weather issues. And if your place has an HOA? You can expect additional monthly dues that can range from $100 to over $1,000.

But let’s not forget maintenance. These costs are often underestimated. Think of routine expenses like landscaping, power washing, chimney cleaning, HVAC servicing, gutter leaning etc. There’s also the more occasional maintenance expenses or even big-ticket repairs which can be infrequent but costly. 

I generally don’t believe in rule of thumbs in personal finance, but we encourage our clients to budget 1%-2% of their home’s value per year for maintenance and repairs. So, for a million dollar home, that’s roughly $10,000 annually, although it’s not necessarily spent all at once, but it adds up. If you’re DIY’ing your financial life, it’s a smart move to build this expense into your cash flow and savings strategy. 

Financial advice handmade with love.

An independent planning-first advisory firm with expertise in equity compensation. Our therapy-like approach helps you understand what it’s all for and the steps needed to get there.

Choosing the right mortgage

Choosing the right mortgage isn’t just about getting the lowest rate.  It’s about choosing a loan that fits your lifestyle, your timeline, and your cash flow. A 30-year fixed mortgage gives you predictability. You’ll know exactly what your monthly payment is, and that peace of mind can be worth a slightly higher rate. It’s a great fit if you value stability or plan to stay in the home for the long haul.

A 15-year mortgage helps you build equity faster and pay less interest over time. But the higher monthly payment can be a stretch, especially in high-cost areas.

Then there are adjustable-rate mortgages (ARMs). They often start with a lower rate for the first 5 to 7 years, which can be appealing if you don’t plan to stay in the home that long. But when that rate adjusts, your payment could increase and you need to be ready for that.

While there are pros and cons to every mortgage, many financial planners (myself included) often recommend starting with a 30-year fixed loan, and here’s why:

It gives you flexibility.

You get the lowest required monthly payment, which gives you breathing room. If you want to pay off your loan faster, you still can by making extra payments toward the principal. But if life throws a curveball (job change, new baby, medical expenses), you’re not locked into the higher payment of a 15-year loan.

Quick story time: One of our clients had the cash flow to afford a 15-year mortgage but chose a 30-year instead. They set up auto-pay to make extra principal payments each month and effectively paid it off in 17 years. Although they could afford the mortgage that made the most financial sense, they chose flexibility to scale back on mortgage payments during years when bonuses didn’t hit or expenses were high.

Lower risk, same payoff speed.. if you’re disciplined.

So if you’re someone who values options and doesn’t mind a little structure, a 30-year loan with accelerated payments can be the best of both worlds.

Don’t try to time the market

Everyone wants to buy at the perfect moment—when home prices dip, rates hit rock bottom, and inventory magically opens up. But the truth is, it’s extremely rare to time it perfectly. And you only really know when you did so in hindsight. 

One client we worked with waited a full year for prices to come down. They watched the market obsessively, refreshed Redfin like it was Instagram and held off because “rates are too high right now.” A year later? Prices were higher, rates weren’t that different and the house they were considering was off the market. 

Another client bought during what felt like a peak. Rates were rising, inventory was tight, and they were nervous. But they had a strong financial foundation, a long-term plan, and the clarity to say: “This is the right move for our life right now.” Three years later, they’re not worried about timing. They’re building equity in a home they love.

That’s the thing: trying to time the market puts the focus on something you can’t control.

Timing your life puts the focus back on you, your needs, your goals, your plan.

So, ask yourself:

  • Am I planning to stay here for the next 7–10 years?
  • Do I have the cash flow and reserves to own responsibly?
  • Would buying this home support my lifestyle or stretch it?

If the answers are solid, you’re likely making a good decision, even if rates change next year or prices dip after you buy. I’ve never met anyone who regrets buying a home they love and can comfortably afford. But I have met people who regret waiting for the perfect market that never came.

The opportunity cost of home ownership

When you buy a home, you’re not just committing to a mortgage. You’re buying an asset and tying up a big chunk of cash..and that has ripple effects. A down payment, closing costs, moving expenses, furniture, renovations..it adds up fast. And once your money is in the house, it’s not exactly liquid. You can’t just sell your kitchen to fund a business idea. 

So, what else could that money be doing?

Could this down payment grow faster elsewhere right now? Will buying limit your ability to invest, take career risks, or stay flexible? Is this the right move for your goals or just what you’ve been told is “smart”?

Don’t get me wrong. Owning a home can be a great way to build wealth over time. But building wealth isn’t about doing what looks good on paper.  It’s about doing what actually works for your life.

We’ve had many clients have a preference toward buying a home simply because “renting feels like wasting money.” But when we modeled both options, (buying vs. investing the down payment and staying flexible) they realized homeownership would delay other goals they cared about more: starting a business, taking a sabbatical, and investing aggressively in their 30s. They chose to rent for now, not because buying is bad, but because it wasn’t the best decision right now. 

This isn’t a blanket argument against homeownership. But it is a reminder that buying a home is a lifestyle decision first, and a financial one second. 

Emotions will creep in. Plan anyway.

This is the part no one warns you about: Buying your first home isn’t just a financial decision. It’s emotional. Deeply emotional.

That’s why we preach to our clients to plan before you fall in love. Set your max budget in advance, and stick to it. Have your monthly comfort range clearly defined and don’t just jump at what the lender approves. You can absolutely buy a home that you feel connected to emotionally. Just don’t let that connection run the numbers for you. Emotion is part of the process. But the plan keeps you grounded. 

Buying a home is a big decision, but it doesn’t have to be permanent. If it fits your goals, budget, and lifestyle for the next 5 to 10 years, you’re in a good spot. If not? Renting is still building your financial foundation,  just in a different way.

Thinking about buying? Hit us up and let’s run the numbers together. We’ll build a plan that fits your life, not just what society thinks.

See if We’re a Fit

Schedule an intro call